FAQs added
We added FAQs to this page.
Osteopenia refers to a decrease in bone mineral density that results in reduced bone strength and an increased risk of broken bones. In osteopenia, bone mineral density is below average, but not severe enough to be considered osteoporosis. Osteopenia occurs naturally with advancing age, but may be aggravated by lifestyle factors (e.g., sedentary lifestyle, poor nutrition), genetics, medication use, or certain disease states.
Osteopenia falls under theJoints & Bonescategory.The Examine Database covers Vitamin K.
Last Updated:July 11, 2023
Osteopenia describes a state of decreased bone mineral density (BMD), in which bone density is below normal but not low enough to be considered osteoporosis.[1] BMD is correlated with bone strength, which is reduced in osteopenia, increasing the risk of bone fractures (broken bones).[2][3] In some people, osteopenia may progress to osteoporosis, which further increases the risk of fractures, disability, and death.[3][1]
A 2022 meta-analysis including participants from 30 different countries estimated the global prevalence of osteopenia to be 40.4%, although rates varied widely between countries and developing countries had the highest prevalence. Postmenopausal women are disproportionately affected by reduced BMD due to reductions in estrogen, but men are also impacted by low BMD. This global meta-analysis reported higher rates of osteopenia in men than in women, but higher rates of osteoporosis in women, indicating that women are more likely than men to progress to osteoporosis.[4]
Osteopenia, or low bone density, usually does not cause any symptoms. Sometimes the first sign of osteopenia will be a fragility fracture, which is when a bone breaks from an impact that would normally not cause a fracture in a healthy individual (e.g., falling from standing height). However, in many people osteopenia may go unrecognized.[5]
Osteopenia is diagnosed by measuring BMD at the hip, forearm, or spine. The gold standard test for measuring BMD is a dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scan, and osteopenia is diagnosed when BMD is 1−2.5 standard deviations below the average BMD for a young, healthy individual of the same sex. When measuring BMD, this is referred to as a T-score, and therefore a T-score between −1 and −2.5 is diagnostic for osteopenia. Similarly, a T-score of −2.5 or lower is diagnostic for osteoporosis.[5]
After diagnosis, blood tests are used to check levels of calcium, phosphorus, vitamin D, thyroid hormones, parathyroid hormone, and testosterone in men, as well as to assess liver and kidney function. These tests can help identify underlying issues that may be contributing to reduced BMD.[5][6]
Bone fractures can cause pain, reduce mobility, and create challenges in performing activities of daily living. Fractures of the hip or spine can even increase the risk of death. Therefore, the focus of osteopenia treatment is to prevent fractures and slow or stop the progression to osteoporosis.[3] Lifestyle modifications are the mainstay of treatment in osteopenia,[6] These include:
Maintaining adequate levels of calcium and vitamin D is important for optimizing bone health and preventing fractures and the progression to osteoporosis. Calcium is a key mineral involved in bone formation and the maintenance of bone strength, while vitamin D promotes calcium absorption and helps to regulate bone turnover. If levels of calcium and vitamin D remain inadequate from diet and sunlight exposure, then supplementation is recommended.[5]
Vitamin K is indirectly involved in the maintenance of healthy bones, and supplementation does seem to reduce markers of bone turnover; however, it’s unclear from the current evidence whether this translates to increases in BMD or a reduced risk of fractures.[7][8][9]
Soy isoflavones, which are structurally similar to estrogen, may have beneficial effects on menopause-related reductions in BMD. However, more research is needed to clearly establish this effect and to determine the ideal dosage and source of isoflavones (i.e., soy protein or isoflavone extracts). Interestingly, these effects may be mediated in part by the gut microbiota which convert isoflavones into active metabolites.[10][11][12]
Other supplements, including magnesium and creatine, show some promise in preliminary studies, but more research is needed to confirm their effects.[13][14]
Diet is an important contributor to bone health. A 2019 meta-analysis of observational studies found that Western dietary patterns, including high consumption of red and processed meats, refined grains, fried foods, and sweets, were associated with an increased risk of low BMD and fractures.[15] Alternatively, healthy dietary patterns like a Mediterranean diet and those containing more dairy products have been associated with a reduced risk of low BMD and fractures.[15][16] These healthy dietary patterns provide important nutrients for bone health, including calcium, potassium, B vitamins, magnesium, vitamin D, vitamin K, and vitamin C.[15][5]
Healthy dietary patterns, including adequate calcium intake in adolescence and throughout the lifespan, are important for attaining adequate peak bone mass between ages 20 and 30, and for minimizing age-related reductions in BMD afterward.[5]
Medications are generally reserved for people with osteopenia who have a particularly high risk of fractures (as determined by a clinician). People with an osteopenia T-score (−1 to −2.5) and a 10-year fracture risk of 20% or more (measured using tools like the Fracture Risk Assessment Tool, FRAX) may be started on medication to increase bone density.[5][6] These same medications are used for the treatment of more severe bone loss or osteoporosis. The most commonly used medications are bisphosphonates (risedronate, alendronate, etc.), which reduce bone breakdown; however, prolonged use can increase the risk of atypical fractures of the femur bone, and therefore continuous use is generally limited to 3 to 5 years. Other medications include estrogen and/or progestin hormone-replacement therapies, selective estrogen receptor modulators (raloxifene), calcitonin, teriparatide, and denosumab.[5][6]
The loss of bone mass with age is a natural process that generally begins after age 30. Bones are in a constant state of remodeling (being built and broken down), and when bone breakdown begins to exceed bone building, gradual reductions in bone density occurs, and over time osteopenia may result.[6] The rate that bone loss leads to osteopenia is highly dependent on genetics, but it is also influenced by modifiable factors beginning in adolescence including physical activity levels, body mass, nutritional status, and the levels of various hormones. Certain disease states, medications, and lifestyle practices may also contribute to an accelerated loss of bone density.[5][6]
Participants: 4800
Unlock the full potential of Examine
In this meta-analysis of 17 randomized controlled trials that included 4,800 middle-aged and older adults, supplementing with vitamin K had no apparent effect on bone mineral density.
Quick Summary
In this meta-analysis of 17 randomized controlled trials that included 4,800 middle-aged and older adults, supplementing with vitamin K had no apparent effect on bone mineral density.
The study
In 7 studies, the participants had osteoporosis or osteopenia, and in the other 10 studies, the participants did not have a diagnosed health condition.
In 11 studies, the participants supplemented with vitamin K2 (ranging from 50 µg to 100 mg per day), and in 6 studies, they supplemented with vitamin K1 (ranging from 9.4 µg to 5 mg per day). The intervention duration ranged from 4 weeks to 4 years.
Vitamin K increased bone mineral density at the lumbar spine, but a sensitivity analysis revealed that after the removal of one study, there was no longer a statistically significant effect. There was also no effect on bone mineral density at the femoral neck, total hip, or distal radius.
The results
Fourteen studies had a high risk of bias, and there was high heterogeneity detected in most of the analyses. These limitations reduce our confidence in the results.
Atque vel expedita ipsum fuga tenetur saepe blanditiis saepe. Ducimus debitis minima fugit. Earum corporis laudantium deserunt architecto vero voluptatum. Quae accusantium eaque. Pariatur quisquam amet libero officiis voluptate corporis in. Eius cum possimus minus suscipit quis illum aliquam. Laborum sunt dolore dolorum ipsam. Earum neque nulla a eligendi.
What was studied?
The association between dietary patterns — particularly a lacto-ovo-vegetarian diet — and the prevalence of osteosarcopenia, which involves a loss of both bone density (osteopenia) and muscle mass (sarcopenia), among older adults.
How was it studied?
Examine Insiders can read two study summaries for any topic on Examine.
Get started with your free account.
What were the results?
Examine Insiders can read two study summaries for any topic on Examine.
Get started with your free account.
The big picture
Examine Insiders can read two study summaries for any topic on Examine.
Get started with your free account.
Anything else I need to know?
Examine Insiders can read two study summaries for any topic on Examine.
Get started with your free account.
Facilis velit accusamus cupiditate soluta asperiores distinctio. Beatae beatae ratione delectus excepturi modi velit. Quod cumque commodi error. Eligendi ipsam quaerat non cupiditate similique. Sunt quaerat tempore harum libero odit minus eveniet cupiditate. Qui neque nisi architecto consectetur omnis voluptatem dolorum expedita ab. Praesentium quas voluptatibus. Cum ducimus quas. Quibusdam numquam magni maiores repellendus quae hic hic earum omnis.
What was studied?
The effects of a multispecies probiotic supplement on bone turnover markers in postmenopausal women.
The primary outcome was the level of C-terminal telopeptide of type 1 collagen (CTX; a marker of bone resorption). The secondary outcome was the serum level of N-terminal propeptide of type 1 procollagen (P1NP; a marker of bone formation).
How was it studied?
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.What were the results?
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.The big picture
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.Anything else I need to know?
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.Omnis placeat in fugit corporis. Est quas aliquid necessitatibus labore. Eos odit repellat blanditiis aspernatur aliquid unde similique tempora. Deserunt libero earum veniam laboriosam eos eos. Voluptate sed voluptatibus unde impedit possimus expedita. Repudiandae unde dolorum dolorum dolore doloribus fuga. Laborum ipsam sunt inventore amet deserunt eveniet maiores. Laudantium eligendi fugiat dolorem dolorum reprehenderit. Nulla similique dolorem inventore. Deserunt asperiores tempora dolor sint expedita.
What was studied?
The effects of high-intensity resistance training (HIRT) on intermuscular adipose tissue (IMAT; fatty infiltration) in the paraspinal muscles among older men with osteopenia and sarcopenia.
IMAT is a measure of fatty tissue infiltration of muscles and may be an early predictor of muscle degeneration.[1]
How was it studied?
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.What were the results?
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.The big picture
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.Anything else I need to know?
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.Ipsum at quibusdam corporis cumque reprehenderit consequuntur autem vitae. Eius expedita eveniet aperiam nulla cupiditate pariatur eligendi. Reiciendis reprehenderit placeat quasi libero dolorem voluptatem eligendi optio atque. Commodi dicta occaecati consequuntur aliquid dignissimos ducimus incidunt. Sit perferendis architecto asperiores nesciunt sint alias debitis adipisci sed. Earum aliquam delectus sit alias. Quos nulla ab sunt explicabo labore rerum officia porro. Amet hic nemo tenetur ipsum. At recusandae cupiditate. Repellat provident laborum tenetur iste excepturi.
What was studied?
The effects of adding supplemental vitamin D to exercise interventions on lumbar spine and/or hip bone mineral density (BMD), compared to the effects of exercise alone.
How was it studied?
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.What were the results?
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.The big picture
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.Anything else I need to know?
Get the latest evidence-based nutrition and supplement information, presented by a team of experts. Save time and money by learning what works.
Get started with Examine+ today.Bone fractures can cause pain, reduce mobility, and create challenges in performing activities of daily living. Fractures of the hip or spine can even increase the risk of death. Therefore, the focus of osteopenia treatment is to prevent fractures and slow or stop the progression to osteoporosis.[3] Lifestyle modifications are the mainstay of treatment in osteopenia,[6] These include:
When done consistently, exercise helps to strengthen bones and muscles which can improve balance and overall functioning, and reduce the risk of falls and fractures. Most forms of exercise, including resistance, aerobic, mind-body, or combined programs, can increase BMD to some degree.[1]
Resistance training has been shown to improve BMD of the lumbar spine, femoral neck, and possibly hip, as well as increase levels of overall physical functioning and health-related quality of life.[17][2][1][3] Interestingly, mind-body exercises (e.g, Tai Chi, qi gong), which often involve a half-squatting position paired with core stabilization and bending, stretching, and rotating from the hips and spine, were suggested to be the optimal exercise type for increasing BMD of the lumbar spine and femoral neck in a 2022 meta-analysis.[1]
In terms of reducing fall risk, a 2019 Cochrane review reported that exercise programs combining balance and functional strength exercises (e.g., squats, sit-to-stands) were the most beneficial.[18]
Diet is an important contributor to bone health. A 2019 meta-analysis of observational studies found that Western dietary patterns, including high consumption of red and processed meats, refined grains, fried foods, and sweets, were associated with an increased risk of low BMD and fractures.[15] Alternatively, healthy dietary patterns like a Mediterranean diet and those containing more dairy products have been associated with a reduced risk of low BMD and fractures.[15][16] These healthy dietary patterns provide important nutrients for bone health, including calcium, potassium, B vitamins, magnesium, vitamin D, vitamin K, and vitamin C.[15][5]
Healthy dietary patterns, including adequate calcium intake in adolescence and throughout the lifespan, are important for attaining adequate peak bone mass between ages 20 and 30, and for minimizing age-related reductions in BMD afterward.[5]
Despite protein being a critical component of bone structure, the impact of protein consumption on BMD has long been debated. Protein intake can increase the acid load in the blood, potentially leading to calcium being pulled out of the bone and into the blood to buffer this effect. This led many researchers to suggest that protein might reduce BMD, and this was seemingly supported by studies finding that increasing amounts of dietary protein led to increased excretion of calcium in the urine. However, current research suggests that dietary protein is associated with increased absorption of calcium from the intestine, which could account for the increased amount of calcium excreted in the urine.[19]
A 2017 meta-analysis of randomized controlled and observational trials by the National Osteoporosis Society found that higher intakes of protein may have a protective or neutral effect on BMD, depending on the site examined.[19] These results are supported by another 2017 meta-analysis of observational studies that found that higher protein intake (>0.8 g/kg/day) was associated with a reduced risk of hip fractures, with no indication of negative effects on BMD.[20]
The loss of bone mass with age is a natural process that generally begins after age 30. Bones are in a constant state of remodeling (being built and broken down), and when bone breakdown begins to exceed bone building, gradual reductions in bone density occurs, and over time osteopenia may result.[6] The rate that bone loss leads to osteopenia is highly dependent on genetics, but it is also influenced by modifiable factors beginning in adolescence including physical activity levels, body mass, nutritional status, and the levels of various hormones. Certain disease states, medications, and lifestyle practices may also contribute to an accelerated loss of bone density.[5][6]
There are many factors, both modifiable and non-modifiable, that may increase the risk of osteopenia, including:[4][5][6]
FAQs added
We added FAQs to this page.